Editorial Policy
Editorial Policy
Nalar Komputasi: Journal of Computer Science and Information Systems
Kebijakan Editorial · NAKOM
This Editorial Policy establishes the principles, authority, and responsibilities of all parties involved in the management and publication of Nalar Komputasi. It is intended to safeguard editorial independence, objective assessment, process transparency, and scholarly publication integrity.
1. Introduction
Nalar Komputasi: Journal of Computer Science and Information Systems (NAKOM) is an open-access scholarly journal published by PT Pustaka Sosio Edukasi, Indonesia. The journal applies independent, objective, transparent, and accountable editorial processes to maintain the quality and integrity of scholarly publications.
This Editorial Policy serves as a guideline for the Editor-in-Chief, editors, Editorial Board members, reviewers, and publisher in managing the publication process. It applies to all submitted manuscripts and published articles, whether written in Indonesian or English.
NAKOM publishes three issues annually in April, August, and December.
2. Editorial Principles and Authority
Editorial authority is vested in the Editor-in-Chief and editors who are formally assigned responsibility for handling manuscripts. The Editor-in-Chief is responsible for the overall editorial policy, publication quality, integrity of the evaluation process, and final decisions regarding manuscript acceptance or rejection.
The Editor-in-Chief may delegate manuscript handling to section editors or other editors with expertise relevant to the research topic. Such delegation does not remove the Editor-in-Chief's ultimate responsibility for the integrity of the editorial process.
Editorial decisions must be based on academic and scientific considerations, including:
Scope relevance
Alignment of the manuscript with the journal's aims and scope.
Originality and contribution
Novelty, originality, and contribution to the advancement of knowledge.
Methodology
Appropriateness of the research design, methods, analysis, and reporting.
Scientific validity
Validity of findings, accuracy of interpretation, and quality of discussion.
Editorial decisions must not be influenced by personal, commercial, organizational, political, or external interests unrelated to the scientific merit of the manuscript.
3. Editorial Independence
NAKOM upholds the principle of editorial independence. PT Pustaka Sosio Edukasi, as the publisher, is responsible for providing the administrative, technical, and institutional support necessary for the journal's operation.
The publisher shall not interfere with scholarly assessments or editors' decisions regarding manuscript acceptance, revision, or rejection. Editors exercise their authority in accordance with academic standards, publication ethics, and established journal policies.
Core principle: decisions concerning the scholarly merit and publication suitability of manuscripts are editorial responsibilities and must be based on academic quality and integrity, not on commercial considerations or other irrelevant interests.
4. Manuscript Assessment and Selection
Every manuscript submitted through Open Journal Systems (OJS) undergoes an initial editorial assessment before proceeding to peer review. The initial assessment includes:
- Relevance to the journal's aims and scope.
- Compliance with author guidelines and submission requirements.
- Completeness of submission documents and manuscript information.
- Originality and indications of publication ethics violations.
- Academic suitability and scientific contribution.
Editors may reject manuscripts without external peer review if they fall outside the journal's scope, fail to meet minimum scholarly standards, do not comply with submission requirements, or present serious indications of ethical misconduct.
Manuscripts that satisfy the initial requirements will proceed to peer review in accordance with NAKOM's Peer Review Policy.
5. Fairness and Objectivity
NAKOM is committed to providing fair and equal treatment to all authors. Manuscripts are evaluated on the basis of scholarly quality and scientific merit, without discrimination based on nationality, institutional affiliation, ethnicity, race, religion, gender, political views, age, or the authors' social and economic backgrounds.
An author's financial capacity and institutional affiliation must not influence editorial decisions. Editors and reviewers are required to maintain objectivity, professionalism, and integrity throughout their responsibilities.
6. Editorial Board and Editorial Responsibilities
The Editorial Board consists of academics, researchers, and professionals with relevant expertise and experience in computer science, informatics, information systems, and computing technologies.
The Editorial Board provides academic guidance, contributes to publication quality, advises on journal development, and supports the implementation of editorial policies. Each editor is responsible for:
- Assessing the relevance and academic suitability of manuscripts.
- Selecting reviewers according to relevant areas of expertise.
- Maintaining the confidentiality of manuscript documents and information.
- Identifying and managing potential conflicts of interest.
- Communicating editorial decisions professionally and appropriately.
- Maintaining the integrity and consistency of the publication process.
The names, institutional affiliations, and positions of Editorial Board members are published on the journal's Editorial Team page.
7. Conflicts of Interest
Editors and reviewers must disclose any potential conflicts of interest that may affect the objectivity of manuscript assessment. Conflicts of interest may involve personal, professional, academic, institutional, financial, or other relationships that could compromise independent evaluation.
An editor who has a conflict of interest regarding a manuscript must withdraw from handling that manuscript. It will be reassigned to another editor without such a conflict. The same principle applies to reviewers appointed to evaluate manuscripts.
8. Confidentiality and Publication Integrity
All submitted manuscripts are treated as confidential documents throughout the editorial and peer review processes. Manuscript information, data, and content must not be used for personal purposes or disclosed to unauthorized parties.
NAKOM does not tolerate plagiarism, data fabrication, data falsification, duplicate publication, citation manipulation, peer review manipulation, or any other form of publication misconduct.
Allegations of misconduct will be handled objectively in accordance with applicable publication ethics procedures. When concerns arise after publication, the journal may issue corrections, expressions of concern, or article retractions, depending on the nature and outcome of the investigation.
9. Special Issues and Guest Editors
NAKOM may publish special issues or thematic collections relevant to the journal's aims and scope. When guest editors are involved, their appointment, responsibilities, and authority must remain under the supervision of the Editor-in-Chief.
All manuscripts submitted to special issues must meet the same academic, publication ethics, and peer review standards applied to regular issues. The Editor-in-Chief retains final responsibility for the quality and integrity of all published articles, including those appearing in special issues.
10. Appeals and Complaints
Authors may appeal editorial decisions when they have clear academic grounds and relevant supporting evidence. Appeals and complaints must be submitted professionally through the OJS platform or the journal's official editorial contact.
Each appeal will be reviewed by the Editor-in-Chief or another senior editor who was not involved in the original decision. Complaints will be addressed objectively, proportionately, and in accordance with publication ethics principles. The outcome of the evaluation will be communicated to the relevant parties.
11. Responsibilities for Publication Ethics
All parties involved in NAKOM's publication activities are required to comply with the journal's ethical policies and scholarly publication integrity standards.
This Editorial Policy is implemented alongside other journal policies, including the Peer Review Policy, Publication Ethics, Artificial Intelligence Use Policy, Plagiarism Policy, Conflict of Interest Policy, and Correction and Retraction Policy.
NAKOM refers to the relevant principles and guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) to maintain the integrity of editorial and scholarly publication processes.
Publisher: PT Pustaka Sosio Edukasi · Indonesia
Publication frequency: April, August, and December
Publication languages: Indonesian and English