Peer Review Policy
Peer Review Policy
Nalar Komputasi: Journal of Computer Science and Information Systems (NAKOM)
Policy governing the independent, objective, and confidential assessment of manuscripts.
1. Purpose and Review Model
Nalar Komputasi: Journal of Computer Science and Information Systems (NAKOM) applies a double-blind peer review process to manuscripts that pass the initial editorial screening. Under this model, authors' identities are not disclosed to reviewers, and reviewers' identities are not disclosed to authors. The handling editor retains access to author identities for editorial management purposes.
Peer review evaluates the scholarly quality, originality, methodological appropriateness, validity of findings, relevance to the journal's scope, and contribution of a manuscript to computer science and information systems. The process supports editorial decisions through independent expert assessment.
Review model: Double-blind peer review.
Number of reviewers: At least two independent external reviewers for each manuscript sent to peer review.
Reviewer identities: Not disclosed to authors during the review process.
2. Initial Editorial Screening
Every manuscript submitted through Open Journal Systems (OJS) is first assessed by an editor or the Editor-in-Chief before reviewers are appointed. Initial screening is not a substitute for peer review; it determines whether a submission is suitable to proceed to external assessment.
The initial screening covers:
- relevance to NAKOM's aims and scope;
- the suitability of the article type and compliance with the author guidelines;
- the completeness of required files, metadata, declarations, and supporting documents;
- the clarity of the research purpose, contribution, and scholarly structure;
- initial indications of plagiarism, duplicate publication, or publication ethics concerns; and
- the general suitability of the methodology and presentation for peer review.
The editor may return a manuscript for completion of administrative requirements or reject it at the initial stage if it falls outside the journal's scope, fails to meet minimum requirements, or presents sufficient academic or ethical grounds for rejection. Manuscripts that pass the initial screening proceed to peer review.
3. Reviewer Selection and Number
The editor responsible for a manuscript selects at least two external reviewers based on the relevance of their expertise to the topic, methods, and research content. Reviewers must have relevant academic or professional competence and be able to provide an independent assessment.
Assigned reviewers must not be part of the editorial office handling the manuscript. Before issuing invitations, the editor considers institutional affiliations, scholarly expertise, publication or research experience, and any potential conflicts of interest.
Where reviewer recommendations differ substantially or are insufficient to support an editorial decision, the editor may seek an additional review or conduct further editorial evaluation. Reviewer recommendations inform the decision but do not automatically determine the final outcome.
4. Double-Blind Review Procedure
NAKOM seeks to maintain the anonymity of both parties throughout the review process. To support this model:
- author names, affiliations, acknowledgements, and other information that may identify the authors are removed or anonymized from files sent to reviewers;
- identifying information in document metadata is checked and removed where practicable;
- reviewers must not disclose their identities to authors in review comments or related communications; and
- official communications concerning peer review are conducted through the editor and/or the OJS platform.
Authors are responsible for preparing anonymized files in accordance with the submission guidelines. Editors are responsible for checking files before sharing them with reviewers. Anonymity cannot always be guaranteed, for example when the manuscript content or citations may reveal an author's identity. Reviewers must notify the editor if recognition of an author's identity creates a potential conflict or may affect objectivity.
5. Peer Review Stages
The peer review process is managed through OJS and generally follows these stages:
Reviewer Assignment
The editor selects reviewers with relevant expertise, checks for potential conflicts of interest, and sends invitations together with manuscript information and the review deadline.
Invitation Response and Assessment
Reviewers accept or decline the invitation. Reviewers who accept assess the manuscript and, where relevant, the accompanying supplementary materials, then prepare an evaluation based on the journal's criteria.
Submission of Review Reports
Reviewers submit their recommendations, comments for the authors, and—where necessary—confidential comments for the editor through the OJS review form. Comments must be professional, specific, and directed toward improving the manuscript's scholarly quality.
Editorial Evaluation and Decision
The editor evaluates the reports, considers the consistency of the recommendations, and makes an editorial decision. The editor may request clarification, an additional reviewer, or another review round when necessary.
Author Revision
When revisions are requested, authors upload a revised manuscript and a detailed response to reviewer comments through OJS. The editor assesses the response and may send the revised manuscript back to reviewers.
Final Decision
After the evaluation and revision process is considered satisfactory, the editor decides whether to accept or reject the manuscript. Accepted manuscripts proceed to copyediting and production; acceptance does not mean immediate publication before the production process is completed.
6. Reviewer Assessment Criteria
Reviewers are asked to assess manuscripts comprehensively, taking into account the following aspects as appropriate to the type and nature of the research:
Originality and novelty
Originality of the idea, novelty of the approach, and contribution to knowledge or practice.
Relevance and contribution
Alignment with the journal's scope and significance to computer science or information systems.
Methodology
Appropriateness of the research design, computational methods, data, procedures, experiments, and analytical techniques.
Results and discussion
Validity of findings, sufficiency of evidence, accuracy of interpretation, and connection between the discussion and research objectives.
References and scholarly foundation
Relevance, currency, citation accuracy, and adequacy of the scholarly literature.
Clarity of presentation
Article structure, language quality, tables, figures, research reproducibility, and completeness of information.
Reviewers should also raise relevant concerns about research ethics, data or code availability where applicable, security, privacy, and potential conflicts of interest. Assessments must focus on the scholarly content rather than the personal characteristics of the authors.
7. Reviewer Recommendations and Editorial Decisions
Reviewers provide recommendations to the editor. The final decision rests with the editor responsible for the manuscript or the Editor-in-Chief. Reviewer recommendations are not automatically binding on the editor.
Accept
The manuscript is acceptable without substantive revision and may proceed to editing and production.
Minor Revision
The manuscript requires limited changes that do not fundamentally alter the research design or conclusions.
Major Revision / Resubmit for Review
The manuscript requires substantial changes. After revision, it may be returned to reviewers for another review round.
Reject
The manuscript does not meet the journal's scholarly, ethical, or scope requirements and cannot proceed toward publication.
In OJS, the editor records the decision using the available editorial actions, such as Accept Submission, Request Revisions, or Decline Submission. A revision request may be followed by another review round when the requested changes require further reviewer assessment. The editor communicates the decision, its rationale, and relevant comments to the authors through OJS.
When reviewers substantially disagree, the editor may seek an additional assessment or explain the basis of the editorial decision. Final acceptance is granted only after the editor determines that all scholarly and editorial requirements have been met.
8. Review and Revision Time Targets
To provide clarity to authors and reviewers, NAKOM sets the following operational targets. Actual deadlines are stated in reviewer invitations or editorial decision letters through OJS and may be adjusted according to manuscript complexity, reviewer availability, and the need for additional review rounds.
| Initial editorial screening | Target: within 7 working days after the submission is confirmed complete. |
|---|---|
| Completion of review | Target: 21 calendar days from the reviewer's acceptance of the assignment. |
| Minor revision | Target: 14 calendar days from the date the revision decision is communicated. |
| Major revision | Target: 30 calendar days from the date the revision decision is communicated. |
| First decision | The journal aims to provide an initial decision within approximately 6–8 weeks after a complete submission. The actual period may be longer if an additional reviewer or further review round is needed. |
If a reviewer or author needs additional time, an extension request must be submitted to the editor before the deadline. If a significant delay occurs, the editor will inform the authors of the progress. Authors may contact the editor through OJS to request an update or withdraw a manuscript in accordance with the journal's procedures.
Note: These periods are NAKOM's editorial service targets, not a guarantee that every manuscript will receive a decision or be published within the stated time.
9. Reviewer Ethics, Confidentiality, and Conflicts of Interest
Reviewers must treat manuscripts, data, supplementary materials, editorial correspondence, and review reports as confidential information. Information obtained during review must not be used for personal advantage, the reviewer's own research, or the benefit of another party before it is lawfully available to the public.
Reviewers must not contact authors directly about a manuscript without the editor's permission, share the manuscript with another person, or ask another person to conduct the review on their behalf without the editor's prior approval. Reviewers must promptly notify the editor if they identify a conflict of interest, lack sufficient expertise, or cannot complete the review objectively and on time.
Reviewers must provide comments that are courteous, evidence-based, and constructive. Insulting, discriminatory, threatening, or irrelevant comments are unacceptable. Reviewers should also inform the editor of suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data manipulation, inappropriate citation practices, or other ethical concerns, without conducting an investigation beyond their role.
10. Use of Artificial Intelligence in Peer Review
Prohibition on reviewer use of AI: NAKOM reviewers must not use artificial intelligence-based tools or services to read, upload, summarize, analyze, evaluate, or generate comments or recommendations on manuscripts under review.
Reviewers must conduct assessments based on their own expertise, academic judgment, and independent analysis. Manuscripts, data, figures, supplementary materials, review reports, and editorial correspondence must not be uploaded or entered into generative AI services or other external applications.
This requirement protects confidentiality, copyright, research data, and authors' intellectual property, while preserving the independence of scholarly assessment. The use of AI in peer review is governed by applicable national requirements and NAKOM's separately published AI Policy.
11. Appeals, Complaints, and Additional Review Rounds
Authors may appeal an editorial decision when there are clear academic grounds, a procedural error, or evidence that the journal's policy has not been properly applied. Appeals must be submitted in writing through OJS or the journal's official editorial contact, identifying the disputed decision and providing supporting reasons.
An appeal is reviewed by the Editor-in-Chief or another senior editor who was not involved in the original decision, where practicable. An appeal does not guarantee that the decision will be changed. The outcome is communicated to the author and constitutes the final editorial decision under the journal's procedures.
The editor may initiate additional review rounds when revisions affect important aspects of the manuscript or further assessment is needed. All rounds and decisions are recorded in OJS to maintain an editorial record.
12. Responsibilities and Final Statement
Editors are responsible for ensuring that reviews comply with journal policy, selecting competent and independent reviewers, protecting confidentiality, managing conflicts of interest, and recording decisions in OJS. Reviewers are responsible for the accuracy, objectivity, confidentiality, and timeliness of their reports. Authors are responsible for responding honestly and comprehensively to reviewer comments.
NAKOM may revise this policy when necessary to reflect developments in scholarly publishing practices, ethical standards, national requirements, and journal management needs. Any policy changes will be published on the journal's official website.
Principles and references: Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers; Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ), Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing (Version 5.0, October 2026); and Decree of the Director General of Science and Technology No. 374/DST/D.D1/HM.01.01/2026 on the Technical Guidelines for Scientific Journal Accreditation.
This policy applies to all manuscripts handled by Nalar Komputasi: Journal of Computer Science and Information Systems (NAKOM).