Plagiarism Policy

AROGYA · PUBLICATION INTEGRITY POLICY

Arogya: Journal of Public Health and Health Services in Indonesia upholds originality, proper source attribution, transparent reporting, and the reliability of the scholarly record. This policy sets out how the journal prevents, screens, and handles suspected plagiarism, text recycling, and duplicate or overlapping publications in submitted manuscripts and published articles.

  • Similarity screening before peer review
  • Context-based editorial assessment
  • No automatic percentage threshold
  • COPE-guided procedures
  • ICMJE and Indonesian guidance considered

1. Definitions and forms of misconduct

Plagiarism is the use of another person’s work, ideas, wording, data, or scholarly material without adequate acknowledgement, in a way that presents it as the submitting author’s own work or contribution. Plagiarism may involve text as well as non-textual material.

Text and idea plagiarism

  • Taking sentences, paragraphs, ideas, argument structures, or findings from another source without proper citation.
  • Rewriting part or all of another person’s work without genuinely expressing it in the author’s own language; this may remain problematic even when a source is cited if the wording substantially reproduces the source.
  • Translating another author’s work and presenting it as one’s own.
  • Citing a secondary source as though the primary source had been consulted.

Plagiarism of material and data

  • Using another party’s data, tables, charts, illustrations, photographs, clinical images, instruments, or supplementary materials without citation and any required permission.
  • Taking another researcher’s analyses or interpretations without acknowledgement.
  • Using copyrighted material without permission where permission is required.

Text recycling and self-reuse

Text recycling occurs when authors reuse portions of their own previously published text without adequate disclosure or citation. It should be distinguished from plagiarism of another person’s work and assessed in light of the amount, location, function, acknowledgement, and effect of the reused text on the novelty of the manuscript.

Duplicate and overlapping publication

Duplicate publication occurs when substantially the same findings or material are published again without clear reference and explanation. Duplicate submission occurs when the same manuscript is submitted to more than one journal at the same time. These are publication-integrity concerns even when they are not plagiarism in the narrow sense.

Data fabrication, data falsification, image manipulation, improper authorship, and undisclosed competing interests are distinct forms of research or publication misconduct. When identified, they may be handled under Arogya’s Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement and other relevant policies.

2. Originality and prior dissemination

Manuscripts submitted to Arogya must be original, must not have been published as a journal article, and must not be under simultaneous consideration by another journal. Authors must disclose material that has previously been disseminated or is substantially related to the submitted manuscript.

Preprints and conference abstracts

Authors must disclose whether the manuscript or an earlier version has been made available as a preprint, conference abstract, poster, repository item, or other public dissemination. For preprints, provide the link and version details. Disclosure allows editors to assess novelty, transparency, and relationships between versions; the existence of a preprint is not automatically treated as plagiarism.

Use of the same dataset

More than one article may arise from a dataset when each addresses a distinct research question and makes a meaningful scholarly contribution. Authors must disclose related publications, cite earlier reports, explain differences in analysis, and avoid dividing findings into multiple papers that lack an independent contribution.

Translations and secondary publication

A translation or secondary publication must not be submitted as a new study without disclosure. It may be considered only after consultation and approval by the relevant editors, acknowledgement of the primary publication, compliance with copyright requirements, and transparent disclosure to readers in accordance with ICMJE guidance.

Material from prior academic work

Material drawn from a thesis, dissertation, research report, or institutional repository must be disclosed to the editor and appropriately cited where relevant. Editors assess its prior-publication status, degree of overlap, institutional requirements, and the new contribution made by the manuscript.

Authors must not submit the same manuscript, in the same or a different language, to multiple journals simultaneously. If a related manuscript, preliminary report, secondary analysis, or earlier publication from the same dataset exists, authors must provide the relevant information and supporting documents at submission.

3. Similarity screening

The editorial office conducts similarity screening as part of the initial assessment before a manuscript proceeds to peer review. Screening may use text-comparison software available to the editorial office, including services such as Turnitin or iThenticate where available. Software output is an aid to editorial assessment, not a substitute for editorial judgment.

Review of matched sources

Editors review the matched sources and manuscript sections, including whether a match is the author’s own work, a preprint, an earlier publication, or another party’s work.

Assessment of the nature of overlap

Editors determine whether matches arise from properly cited quotations, standard terminology, methods descriptions, references, common phrases, text recycling, or unattributed use of material.

Assessment of novelty and contribution

For health manuscripts, editors may also examine the reuse of data, tables, clinical images, trial results, protocols, or findings previously reported elsewhere.

Editorial decision

The editor determines whether the manuscript may proceed, requires correction or clarification, or should be rejected or referred for further examination because of a serious concern.

No automatic percentage threshold

Arogya does not apply a single similarity percentage as an automatic threshold for concluding plagiarism or rejecting a manuscript. A low score may still conceal serious appropriation of ideas or data, while a higher score may arise from quotations, references, common methods wording, or the authors’ own preprint. Decisions are made only after reviewing the matched sources and context.

Authors are encouraged to check citations, paraphrases, quotations, and references before submission. Authors must not manipulate manuscripts by replacing characters, inserting text as images, or using other techniques to evade similarity screening.

4. Investigation of suspected misconduct

Suspected plagiarism may be identified through editorial screening, a reviewer’s report, a submission by an author, a reader report, another journal editor, or a party providing relevant evidence. Arogya handles reports confidentially, fairly, objectively, and proportionately, with reference to COPE procedures.

  1. Receipt and record of evidence. The editorial office records the report, article or manuscript details, suspected source material, and supporting evidence. Relevant document versions and similarity reports are retained for examination.
  2. Preliminary assessment. The editor considers whether the report has a reasonable basis, assesses the extent and nature of overlap, and distinguishes plagiarism from text recycling or overlapping publication that may be explainable.
  3. Request for clarification. Where appropriate, the corresponding author and/or all authors are contacted in writing. The editorial office explains the concern and relevant evidence and gives the authors a reasonable opportunity to respond and provide supporting documentation.
  4. Assessment of the explanation. The editor evaluates the response alongside the available evidence. The editor may request original sources, permissions, details of related publications, or clarification about the origin of data and images.
  5. Editorial decision and follow-up. The editor determines a proportionate editorial action. For serious, repeated, disputed, or institution-level concerns, the journal may contact the authors’ institution or another relevant authority in accordance with COPE guidance.

The journal’s assessment does not replace an institution’s authority to conduct a formal investigation into research misconduct. Arogya may make an editorial decision based on the evidence available without waiting for an institutional process to finish when the integrity of the scholarly record needs protection.

5. Actions before and after publication

Before publication

  • Limited and correctable overlap: authors may be asked to revise paraphrasing, add citations, clarify attribution, or obtain required permissions.
  • Text reuse requiring explanation: editors may ask authors to explain prior publications, revise overlapping sections, cite earlier work, or disclose relationships between manuscripts.
  • Substantial plagiarism, misattributed data/images, undisclosed duplicate publication, or duplicate submission: the manuscript may be rejected. The editorial office may request clarification and, where relevant, refer the concern to the appropriate institution.

After publication

  • Correction: may be issued when the problem is limited and the scholarly record remains reliable after correction and proper attribution.
  • Expression of Concern: may be issued when a serious concern is still under investigation and readers need to be alerted.
  • Retraction: may be issued where substantial plagiarism, duplicate publication, copyright infringement, or another problem materially undermines the originality or reliability of the article.

Post-publication actions are accompanied by a clear, traceable notice linked to the article record. Corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions are intended to preserve the accuracy of the scholarly record, not merely to punish authors. Editors consider the nature, extent, location, impact, and evidence of the misconduct in accordance with COPE guidance.

6. Specific considerations for health research

In health research, the integrity of scholarly material is directly related to patient safety, privacy, and the reliability of evidence that may influence health practice or policy. Editorial screening may therefore include the following considerations.

Research data and findings

Reuse of datasets, clinical outcomes, tables, or analyses from another publication must be disclosed and cited. Authors must explain the new contribution of a secondary analysis and must not present previously reported findings as independent results.

Clinical photographs and patient data

Photographs, radiographs, test results, or clinical materials must be used with an appropriate ethical basis, consent, privacy protection, and copyright permission. Using another party’s material without attribution or permission may violate rights and publication integrity.

Instruments and protocols

Questionnaires, scales, diagnostic instruments, protocols, and intervention materials developed by others must be cited. Authors must obtain permission for use or adaptation where required by the rights holder or instrument conditions.

Multiple reports from one study

Articles derived from the same clinical trial, cohort, survey, or dataset must cite the primary report and the study registration where applicable, disclose the relationship between manuscripts, and demonstrate a distinct research question or analysis with a substantial contribution.

Image manipulation, data falsification, fabrication of findings, or omission of information that changes the interpretation of results are treated as suspected research-integrity violations and may be handled together with Arogya’s Publication Ethics policy.

7. Responsibilities of authors

  • Ensure that the manuscript is original and that all sources used are properly acknowledged.
  • Use quotations and paraphrases accurately and ensure that all in-text citations match the reference list.
  • Disclose related manuscripts, prior publications, preprints, conference abstracts, theses/dissertations, and use of the same dataset.
  • Do not submit the same manuscript to more than one journal at the same time.
  • Obtain written permission for third-party material when required and retain evidence of permission.
  • Explain the new contribution when the manuscript is a secondary analysis or part of a study previously reported elsewhere.
  • Respond honestly, fully, and promptly to editorial requests for clarification.
  • Comply with Arogya’s AI policy; AI use does not remove the authors’ responsibility to verify originality, citation accuracy, and the truthfulness of the entire manuscript.

8. Reporting suspected misconduct

Authors, reviewers, readers, editors, publishers, or other parties may report suspected plagiarism, unattributed reuse of material, duplicate publication, or copyright infringement to the Arogya editorial office.

Arogya editorial office info@pustakaedukasi.com

Please include the article title or DOI (if published), the section of concern, links to the comparison sources, and supporting evidence. The identity of the reporter and information received will be handled carefully and restricted to those involved in the assessment.

9. Guidelines and official resources

Arogya’s policy is informed by the following sources. Links lead to the original publisher or issuing body.